Skip to Content


Is It Bad Luck to Buy a Used Diamond Wedding Ring?

Is It Bad Luck to Buy a Used Diamond Wedding Ring?

When it comes to second-hand goods, especially diamonds, it is essential to check the quality in detail, whether they have a certificate or not, and many other things.

That is important because you can prevent making a mistake when buying a wedding ring that has already been used. A frequently asked question about buying used diamond rings is: Is it bad luck to buy a used diamond wedding ring?

A correct answer would undoubtedly be: A used engagement ring will be of equal quality to a new engagement ring as long as you get it from a reputable jeweler. Unfortunately, most pre-owned engagement rings today were sold by their original owners for monetary reasons.

This article will explain everything you need to know about used wedding diamond rings and much more.

Let’s get started!

Where Do You Find Used Diamond Rings?

Unbelievable as it may seem, there are now entire companies just focused on selling used jewelry. It is no longer necessary to enter a pawn shop.

You’ll probably prefer more comparison shopping from the comfort of your home online without having to deal with pushy salespeople.

So that is why we have selected for you some of the best shopping sites, which are:

1. eBay

We strongly believe eBay is the king of the second-hand diamond rings market all over the world. The selection of used engagement rings is the finest, and there are more than 7,000 used diamond rings available.

That large number may seem intimidating, but eBay’s filtering options are simple and typically accurate, provided the seller has put in sufficient work with classification.

2. Etsy

Some of the diamond rings on Etsy are actually “antique” and, in our opinion, rather pricey, while others are simply second-hand engagement rings.

The selection is not as extensive as on eBay, and the prices are fixed rather than auctioned, but it is still worth a look.

3. Preloved

Preloved may not provide the same level of buyer protection as eBay, but there are some excellent deals to be gained if you are ready to pay cash to an internet seller.

It’s a classified ad website, with a search for engagement rings yielding over 500 results.

Related Read: Diamond Buying Guide: How to Choose a Diamond?

Do You Inform Your Lover The Ring Is “Used”?

You’ll undoubtedly hear a lot of discussions when ring-shopping regarding whether or not you “have to” inform the recipient of the gift where you acquired it.

And although we can’t speak for you, we don’t believe it is a good sign to begin your brand-new engagement by not being completely honest. And of course, we don’t mean you inform them in the middle of the proposition.

When it comes to second-hand engagement rings, your spouse will either be fine with it or will feel strongly that wearing a memento of another couple’s failed marriage is unfortunate.

If you follow your stars, keep track of your karma points, and live by your horoscope, perhaps a used engagement ring isn’t for you.

However, if you don’t believe in astrology or even sometimes check your zodiac (we are sure all of us sometimes check it, whether you believe in it or not), it might be time to start exploring elsewhere.

In addition, perhaps the ring will be lucky for you this time – especially if you can get it at a much more reasonable price.

Is It Bad Luck to Buy a Used Diamond Wedding Ring?

Not all used engagement rings originate from persons who have had their engagements or marriages ended. Though some people utilize the money to buy a new ring, this usually implies they desire a different ring design, stone cut, or carat weight.

Unfortunately, some individuals could assert that using engagement rings results in failed relationships. As a result, one might find themselves with cursed or undesirable jewelry.

Honestly, buying used jewelry wouldn’t be the wisest purchase for someone who heavily believes in superstitions, horoscopes, and karma points.

Maybe you would never feel comfortable wearing any previously owned jewelry pieces if you knew that you would be so disturbed about inheriting someone else’s terrible relationship luck from the same jewelry.

If you don’t believe in superstitions or only sometimes check your zodiac sign, you may always go through a selection of used jewelry.

Perhaps the ring would completely change your life for the better, you never know!

Your personal beliefs will determine if purchasing any used jewelry will be lucky or unlucky for you. Even if it’s mere superstition, if you believe in bad luck, we do not recommend you to buy a used diamond ring.

But, be aware: Many rings come from married couples who want to replace their current rings or try something new. Some could even be brand-new, but they were discounted when sold to a jeweler or merchant to help them get rid of any unsold inventory.

However, this does not change the reality that a tiny percentage of used engagement rings come from broken relationships. They are a minority in that sense.

Relationships only succeed if you want to put up the effort; nevertheless, jewelry does not qualify as a relationship.

Nevertheless, the majority of individuals sell their engagement rings to upgrade to a different ring with a larger stone or to raise money for a fantasy trip.

Related Read: Can Diamonds Be Unlucky?

Is Giving An Old Engagement Ring Unlucky?

There is no real connection between giving a second-hand engagement ring and bad luck.

When superstition is attached to jewelry, the initial vibrations must be removed or neutralized using the same energy.

Some wedding bands are handed down from one generation to the next as family heirlooms. Some families have betrothal rings that go back several hundred years in various nations.

These rings come off and are worn only when the proposal is made. They are then put on for the wedding ceremony and the engagement party.

The bride would wear it for family pictures, after which it would be returned and utilized for the following wedding.

Afterward, the bride would have to wear a stand-in ring for the duration of her marriage.

When the groom’s family presents such engagement rings, it is frequently a sign that they all approve of the woman as a future family member.

Is Purchasing a Wedding Band From a Pawn Shop Unlucky?

Jewelry of excellent quality can be found in pawn shops. When a pawn shop first opens for business, it is the ideal moment to purchase anything from them.

Why, you may wonder? It’s because they must constantly sell goods to be in business.

But wedding bands from pawn shops are not unlucky. Finding the ideal ring for your life partner is one of the luckiest things that may happen to you.

If you buy a wedding ring at retail pricing, you risk becoming bankrupt since it is such a significant investment.

All you need to do is make sure the pawn shop you are working with is respectable.

If you know what to search for, you could discover high-quality wedding rings for less than half the cost of those found at retail jewelry stores.

Reasons To Buy Used Diamond Ring

You may wonder are there any advantages to buying used diamond rings and what are the reasons for buying one. Let’s take a look!

1. Extremely Sharp Devaluation

Diamonds depreciate very rapidly. The diamond in your palm is only worth roughly one-fifth of what you paid for it if you buy it and leave the jeweler’s store.

With such a significant loss, choosing a used ring and saving money is wise. However, this suggests that purchasing a diamond is not always a good investment.

2. Exceptionally Low Resell Value

Because diamonds depreciate fast, it isn’t easy to resell your engagement ring for a fair price. You may not find many customers since jewelers avoid worn diamonds for the same reason.

Other choices include pawn shops and internet forums, although you may not receive a fair deal even there.

3. You Have the Option to Reallocate Your Resources

Any wedding or engagement should have a budget. It would be best if you didn’t overspend on an engagement ring when you have so many other things to save.

Purchasing a used ring frees up funds for other necessities. Make a mortgage payment, buy a gift for your lover, organize a trip, or even embark on a wedding shopping spree!

There is no shortage of things you can do and purchase with the money you save by buying a used engagement ring.

4. There Is Nothing to Be Ashamed Of

There is a common misconception that someone should spend two months’ pay on an engagement ring to show their lover how important they are.

This is more than a diamond-seller-led promotional effort to get customers to pay more for engagement rings.

5. Get More for Your Money

Size counts when it comes to engagement rings. Everyone desires a ring with a large and well-cut stone.

However, if you consider getting a used ring, you may receive a far superior item for a much lesser price. Isn’t that great?

A used 3-carat ring, for example, can be the same price as a brand new 1-carat ring.

6. Diamonds Are Timeless

Diamonds are durable and withstand the test of time. They are virtually impossible to scratch or chip.

Purchasing a used engagement ring does not imply that you have a faulty gemstone. A diamond that has been used for some time will be as lovely as one that has recently been cut.

Given the endurance of diamonds and the difficulty in determining their age, there is no way of knowing whether the diamond ring you just purchased has already been worn.

Related Read: Do Diamonds Wear Down? Can The Hardest Material Wear Out?

7. It Is Beneficial to the Environment

Mining for diamonds, or any other stone, is a problematic procedure.

Buying used diamonds reduces the need to mine new diamonds. You may believe that fewer diamonds will not help the world, yet every single one matters.

Related Read: What Are Negative Effects Of Diamond Mining?

8. One Person’s Misfortune Is Another Person’s Treasure

According to popular belief, worn rings are cursed and can throw an evil shadow on the person who wears them.

Well, karma and luck may be accurate, but if buying a used ring means getting a better item for less money or making your lover even pleased, how can it be anything but good fortune?

Don’t forget – Inanimate things can’t define a future!

9. Antiques Are Always in Style

Antique jewelry is always in trend, and the aged appearance only adds to the ring’s charm and character. When you buy a used ring, you have a far more extensive selection from which to select the right band.

These rings will not only have personality, but you may be lucky enough to locate a ring with a style that is not currently available on the market but is appropriate for your lover.

Also, diamonds are frequently recycled, a little-known truth about jewelry. That center stone may have been in Cartier earrings or Tiffany & Co necklace years ago and could be recycled into a new bracelet years from now.

Learn More: Recycled Diamonds: an Environmentally-friendly Gem Choice?

Final Thoughts

If you’re still wondering “Is It Bad Luck to Buy a Used Diamond Wedding Ring?”

A definitive answer would be: A worn engagement ring will be of equivalent quality to a new engagement ring if purchased from a trustworthy jeweler.

Unfortunately, most pre-owned engagement rings were probably sold for monetary reasons by their original owners.

In addition, we have tried to explain where you could buy a used diamond wedding ring and present you with all the advantages that this purchase can bring you.

We hope you enjoyed gathering information and reading our article as much as we enjoyed telling you all about this topic

Related Read: Which Brand Is The Best For A Diamond Ring?